2025 Restaurant & Winery Award Winners

As voted on by a panel of over 60 food judges representing local media, political, business, and community development sectors.

Chair’s Choice (chosen by Matthew Reis, 2025 Taste of Buffalo Chair): El Coquito Chicharron de Pollo

Children’s Choice (chosen by Cameron Reis, son of 2025 Taste Chair): Not Just Cakes Chocolate Brownie Mousse Cups

Louis J. Billittier Sr. Rookie of the Year Award: Roaming Bison BBQ

Veteran Restaurant Winner: Carrubba’s Chicken Pit

Eric DuVall Memorial Best of Buffalo Winner: Avenue29 Foods Meatball Bomber

Best Overall Item:  Resurgence Brewing Company Barley Brussels

Best New Item: Chrusciki Bakery Cream Puff with Powdered Sugar

Best Surf or Turf Item: La Casa de Sabores Pernil (roasted pork)

Best Dessert: Sweet Melody’s Red White & Blue Sundae

Best Handheld: AJ’s Kitchen Smack Burger

Hot Ones Best Item: D.A. Taste Birria Waffle Fries

Best Red Wine: Merritt Bella Rosa

Best White Wine: Victorianbourg D’Astra

Favorite Fermentation: Three Brothers Concord Grape Hard Cider